What are the policy challenges for the implementation of living-lab-based open schooling in Europe?
Methodology to produce the roadmap
Policy challenges in science education
* Disparities in Basic Science Literacy. Students are likely to enter open schooling programmes with varying base levels of scientific competence: a 2010 study authored for the European Commission (Schlicht et al. 2010) on educational inequality across European Union regions observed significant disparities in the quality and effectiveness of science instruction offered throughout the EU.
* Regional disparities. In regard to general education achievement in the EU, there appears to be a North-South divide: low-performing students are concentrated in southern Europe, while students in Northern European countries display higher levels of competency.
* Rural Areas. Rapid urbanisation across EU member states has also decreased the populations of rural areas and encouraged migration of young people to towns and cities; consequently, a disproportionately low share of the EU’s under-50 population resides in remote areas and schools in these regions tend to be small and underfunded.
* Financial Issues. Open schooling initiatives must be implemented in a way that does not create extra financial burden for students and families.
* Physical and Legal Issues. Although most EU countries have implemented legislation on the subject of ensuring access to education for children with disabilities, monitoring and enforcing these regulations has proved to be a challenge.
* Digital Divide/Access to Technology. As the digital transformation of society and the economy continues, it becomes increasingly important for educational policy to take into account the necessity of technological literacy.
* Lack of Qualified Teachers. Innovative living-lab based open schooling initiatives require teachers who are digitally competent, and who are skilled in managing projects and partnerships with community actors. In 2020, 33% of teachers across the EU were more than 50 years old. Facilitating the entry of digitally adept young professionals into teaching and upskilling of the existing workforce are a crucial policy challenge.
* Families and Culture. Parents and caregivers play a central role in encouraging children’s interest in learning, creating learning opportunities outside of formal educational structures and facilitating appropriate cognitive development.
* Lack of Cooperation. The 2015 Science Education for Responsible Citizenship report criticised inadequate investment in facilitating strategic collaboration between teachers, students, external education providers, researchers and industry professionals.
* Lack of Stakeholder Commitment. Consistent meaningful interaction between educational institutions and third-party stakeholders is crucial to avoid stakeholder disengagement.
* Support System. The European Commission’s 2020 Working Group on Schools Policy, which examined whole school approaches to challenges facing educational systems, concluded that facilitating strong cooperation between teaching staff, parents and families was crucial to prevent student disengagement.
* Student Engagement. It is important to prevent students from disengaging from science learning on the basis of perceived ineptitude. Presenting scientific learning as an ongoing process – rather than one based solely on mastery of a specific set of concepts – may help to sustain student interest in science into and through post-secondary studies.
* Gender Gap. Despite their superior performance on tests of scientific aptitude, women and girls remain significantly underrepresented in STEM-related fields. PISA 2018 found that 14% of top-performing girls in science or mathematics expected to work in science or engineering compared with 26% of top-performing boys.
* Low Interest in Science Studies and Related Careers. While STEM professionals are in high demand, and growth in these sectors is required to address topical concerns ranging from climate change to food and water security, interest in scientific tertiary studies and careers is not picking up.
* Monitoring. Another challenge in implementing open science learning initiatives is the lack of strategies to compare and analyse the outcomes of these programmes. While the EU has historically relied on standardised tests of academic ability like PISA to assess the quality of national education systems, these examinations tend to focus on reading, writing and mathematics at the expense of science.
* Evaluation Issues. It has proven difficult to observe, measure and quantify the contributions of out-of-school programmes to the broader learning ecosystem.
Do you agree with this set of policy challenge?
Do you want to add any other?
Do you want to merge any category?
Do you want to add any policy gap?
Do you think that they cover the entire spectrum of the problem?
Policy recommendations in science education
* Mainstream Open Schooling. Incorporate open schooling in national educational strategies, central policies and curricula, boosting its legitimacy as a fully fledged alternative to more traditional teaching methods, rather than a complementary activity that ultimately is perceived as an optional “add-on.” This can improve stakeholder as well as parents and caretakers engagement and thus support teachers in adopting the SALL methodology. Student engagement with STEM education and potential careers is also likely to benefit from this novel, more flexible approach.
Policy challenges to be addressed:
* Lack of stakeholder commitment (including families)
* Lack of student engagement with STEM subjects
* Low interest in science studies and careers
* Train the Teachers of the Future. Integrate open schooling into teacher training curricula and encourage the development of leadership, facilitation, and project management skills, as well as digital and technological competencies among newly qualified teachers. In parallel, invest in upskilling the existing workforce (lifelong learning), so that teachers and educators familiarise with the tenets and aims of open schooling and can engage with these initiatives.
Policy challenges to be addressed:
* Lack of qualified teachers
* Lack of support systems
* Make Funding Available for Open Schooling Programmes. Create incentives for school management to invest in open schooling initiatives. Taking into account existing disparities in science literacy, schools in under resourced regions and rural areas should be prioritised so that no one is left behind.
Policy challenges to be addressed:
* Regional disparities (North-South, urban-rural)
* Disparities in basic science literacy
* Support Schools in Accommodating Students’ Needs. Open schooling programmes should be designed to be as inclusive as possible. Schools need funding and, where necessary, technical support to fully implement existing legislations and policies to ensure accessibility, and to better support students with disabilities.
Policy challenges to be addressed:
* Physical and legal issues
* Prioritise Skills Development. Promote a shift away from traditional grading, and encourage rigorous monitoring and evaluation of open schooling initiatives. While standardised testing may continue to have some utility in providing consistent measurements of scientific knowledge at the national and international levels, the results of these assessments should not be relied upon solely to evaluate the success of open schooling programmes.
Policy challenges to be addressed:
Do you agree with this set of policy recommendations?
Do you want to add any other?
Do you want to merge any category?
Do you want to add any policy gap?
Do you think that they cover the entire spectrum of the problem?
A Making Speeches Talk Joint!
